How to Appeal a Denied Long-Term Disability Claim in the Greater Toronto Area

Facing a long-term disability (LTD) claim denial is one of the most stressful experiences a person can endure, especially here in the Greater Toronto Area (GTA). You’ve been paying premiums, you’re unable to work due to a serious medical condition, and you rely on these benefits for financial survival. Then, the letter arrives—your claim has been denied.
This denial is often based on the insurance company's interpretation of medical evidence, surveillance reports, or technical policy language. It is crucial to understand that a denial is not the final word. You have legal options, and the appeal process is your next step toward securing the benefits you deserve.
At Benjamin Law Firm, we understand the complex tactics insurance companies use to protect their bottom line. Benjamin Law Firm has some of Greater Toronto Area's Top Personal Injury, Car Accident, Long-Term Disability and Employment Lawyers. Over 3,500 Families Helped. Over $60 Million In Settlements Recovered For Clients. We are here to guide you through the process of challenging that denial effectively and efficiently.
Understanding the Denial and Your Options
The first step after receiving a denial letter is to critically analyze the reasons provided by the insurer. The denial letter should clearly state the grounds for their decision.
Common Reasons for LTD Claim Denial
In the GTA, denials are typically based on a few recurring issues:
- Insufficient Medical Evidence: The insurer claims your doctor’s notes, tests, or reports do not provide objective proof that your disability prevents you from performing your job duties (or any job duties, depending on the definition in your policy).
- Conflict with the Policy Definition: Many policies shift from an "Own Occupation" definition (unable to do your specific job) to an "Any Occupation" definition (unable to do any job for which you are reasonably suited by education, training, or experience) after 24 months. The insurer may deny the claim if they believe you meet the latter definition.
- Surveillance and Social Media: The insurer may hire investigators to observe you or scour your social media accounts. If they find evidence they claim contradicts your stated limitations, they will use it as grounds for denial.
- Technical Issues: This can include missing forms, claims filed past deadlines, or issues with premium payments.
The Two Paths After Denial: Internal Appeal vs. Legal Action
Once denied, you generally face two main choices:
- Internal Appeal (Reconsideration): You submit additional information to the insurer and ask them to reconsider their decision.
- Commencing Legal Action (Lawsuit): You bypass the internal appeal (or pursue it simultaneously) and initiate a lawsuit against the insurance company.
Warning on Internal Appeals: While an internal appeal sounds like the logical next step, it often favors the insurer. It simply gives them a second chance to look at your case with no obligation to reverse their decision, potentially delaying the process and allowing the limitation period for filing a lawsuit to creep closer.
Strategic Legal Action: The Smart Approach to Appeal
For most denied LTD claimants in the GTA, the most effective and decisive path is to bypass the internal appeal and pursue immediate legal action. This sends a clear signal to the insurance company that you are serious and places the decision in the hands of the courts, not the insurer’s in-house reviewers.
1. Reviewing the Policy and Limitation Period
The first and most critical step a lawyer takes is reviewing your specific LTD insurance policy. This policy is the contract that governs everything.
- Understanding the Definitions: We clarify the exact definition of "total disability" in your policy (Own Occupation vs. Any Occupation) and the corresponding benefit payout period.
- The Limitation Period: In Ontario, there are strict deadlines—called limitation periods—for filing a lawsuit. Missing this deadline, typically two years from the date of the denial, means you lose your right to sue forever. A lawyer ensures this critical deadline is met.
2. Gathering Strong, Objective Medical Evidence
The core of any successful appeal lies in objective medical evidence that directly contradicts the insurer's denial reasons.
- Specialist Reports: Your initial documentation may have been insufficient. Your lawyer will coordinate with specialists (e.g., orthopedic surgeons, neurologists, psychologists) to obtain detailed reports. These reports must clearly explain:
- The diagnosis and prognosis.
- The specific functional limitations imposed by the condition (e.g., "cannot sit for more than 30 minutes," "lifting restricted to 5 lbs.").
- Why these limitations prevent you from performing the material duties of your job (or any suitable job).
- Objective Test Results: The insurer often dismisses pain-based claims. Your lawyer will ensure the file is bolstered with objective data like MRIs, CT scans, blood work, or specialized functional capacity assessments (FCAs).
3. Addressing the Insurer's Specific Denials
Your legal strategy must directly confront and dismantle the arguments presented in the denial letter.
- Challenging Surveillance: If surveillance footage is cited, a lawyer can assess whether the footage genuinely contradicts your claim or if it is misleading and taken out of context. For example, a claimant restricted from work who is filmed walking their dog is likely still within their stated limitations.
- "Any Occupation" Claims: If the denial is based on the Any Occupation test, your lawyer will gather evidence proving that your disability prevents you from performing any job for which you are reasonably qualified, not just your former job. This often involves vocational experts.
4. Commencing Litigation and Negotiation
Once legal action is commenced, the dynamic shifts. The insurer now faces the cost and risk of litigation.
- Filing the Statement of Claim: This formal document outlines the legal grounds for your case and the benefits you are seeking, including past arrears, future benefits, and often damages for bad faith (if the denial was particularly egregious).
- Mediation and Settlement: The vast majority of LTD lawsuits settle before trial. Your lawyer will negotiate fiercely on your behalf during mediation to secure a lump-sum settlement or reinstatement of your monthly benefits.
Why Legal Representation is Essential in the GTA
Trying to negotiate or sue a massive insurance corporation on your own is highly inadvisable. They have teams of adjusters, in-house medical consultants, and lawyers whose sole job is to minimize payouts.
Leveling the Playing Field
Insurance law is complex, and the terms and conditions of an LTD policy are often dense and open to interpretation. An experienced LTD lawyer:
- Knows the Case Law: We understand past court decisions that interpret similar policy clauses, giving us leverage in negotiations.
- Manages the Burden: We handle all communications, deadlines, and the stressful administrative work, allowing you to focus entirely on your health and recovery.
- Maximizes Recovery: We not only fight for the benefits you are owed but also for interest and potential damages for bad faith, often resulting in a higher financial recovery than you could achieve alone.
Don't Give Up on Your Benefits
A long-term disability denial is a significant setback, but it is a challenge you can overcome with the right legal strategy. In the competitive legal environment of the Greater Toronto Area, you need advocates who are experienced, aggressive, and committed to your welfare.
At Benjamin Law Firm, we have a proven track record of successfully challenging insurance giants and recovering substantial settlements for our clients. We understand the physical and emotional toll a denial takes and are prepared to fight tirelessly to secure the financial stability you need.
Benjamin Law Firm has some of Greater Toronto Area's Top Personal Injury, Car Accident, Long-Term Disability and Employment Lawyers. Over 3,500 Families Helped. Over $60 Million In Settlements Recovered For Clients. Don't face the insurance company alone.
Book a free consultation with Benjamin Law Firm today to discuss your denied LTD claim and take the first step toward appeal.
Greater Toronto Area's Trusted Personal Injury Law Firm



BOOK YOUR FREE CONSULTATION
Fill out the Case Evaluator form below to discuss your case or claim with one of our experienced Family-First legal professionals. At Benjamin Law, we work hard, and fast to get you justice, to solve your problems, and get you the compensation that you deserve.
